It never ceases to disarm me how naive some Ph.D. students can be about the academic job market. And I’m not the only one.
Even though the undeniable bottoming-out of the tenure-track market has been well-documented, I frequently find myself conversing with grad students or recent Ph.D.s who suggest that they will take “just a research job” or something else to bide their time if they can’t find a tenure-track job, suggesting they haven’t even considered the possibility of finding no job in their field. When pressed, they barely acquiesce, acknowledging that they may have to lower their standards over time and consider openings at non-R1 universities or lower-tier schools. This mentality was VERY prevalent prior to the great recession, but even last week, I overheard the following: “I’m not interested in the job at [XYZ]. It’s like a safety school’s safety school.”
This time of year (end of fall semester), as another academic jobs cycle comes to a close, I start to see a lot more posts and musings about “What else can I do with a Ph.D.?” The answer is: tons! But the problem is that a lot of what’s out there about alt-ac careers is still generally outdated advice.